Amie Maxwell and Kimberly Clay Identified as Victims in Oktaha Shooting, Rolando Donta McConnell’s Death Linked to Suspect Aaron Wilson-Bogar, Authorities Investigate Police-Involved Fatal Shooting and High-Speed Pursuit

March 11, 2025 – Muskogee County, Okla. – In a tragic and complex chain of events, the Muskogee County Sheriff’s Office has identified the victims of the recent fatal shooting at Five Star Recycling in Oktaha, Oklahoma, as Amie Maxwell, who was tragically killed, and Kimberly Clay, who was shot but miraculously survived the ordeal. Authorities have also identified the suspect, Aaron Wilson-Bogar, a 26-year-old man, who was apprehended after a violent altercation with law enforcement that involved two fatal shootings, a high-speed chase, and an officer-involved shooting.

Wilson-Bogar, who had been previously linked to multiple violent crimes, including the fatal shooting of Rolando Donta McConnell in Muskogee, remains under investigation. In the wake of these events, both Sergeant Bryan Wilkins and Officer Darien Allen of the Muskogee Police Department, who were involved in the police shooting that occurred during the high-speed chase, have been placed on administrative leave. This investigation has involved multiple law enforcement agencies, including the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation (OSBI), Muskogee Police Department, and other local authorities.

The Oktaha Shooting Incident

On the weekend of March 8, 2025, an alarming incident unfolded at Five Star Recycling in Oktaha, Muskogee County. The details of the tragic shooting event have left the community reeling in shock. Authorities report that Amie Maxwell, whose age and background are still being confirmed, was fatally shot in a violent attack at the recycling facility. Kimberly Clay, a colleague of Maxwell’s at Five Star Recycling, was also targeted in the shooting but survived, albeit with severe injuries. Her current condition has not been publicly disclosed, but law enforcement confirmed that she was rushed to the hospital following the attack.

While the motive behind the shooting remains unclear, law enforcement has confirmed that the suspect, Aaron Wilson-Bogar, was involved in the tragic event. After the shooting, Wilson-Bogar led authorities on a dramatic high-speed chase across Muskogee County that intensified the already harrowing situation.

The Pursuit and Officer-Involved Shooting

After the fatal shooting in Oktaha, the Muskogee Police Department quickly launched an intensive search for Wilson-Bogar, who had gone on the run. The Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation (OSBI) reports that Wilson-Bogar had already been involved in previous violent incidents, including the shooting death of Rolando Donta McConnell. Law enforcement had no choice but to pursue Wilson-Bogar, as he continued to evade capture and reportedly fired shots at officers during the pursuit.

The high-speed chase that followed was tense and chaotic, involving multiple law enforcement agencies. Officers gave chase across various stretches of highway, with Wilson-Bogar allegedly firing shots at pursuing officers during the chase. The Muskogee Police Department, in its report, stated that once the pursuit came to an end, Wilson-Bogar exited his vehicle and continued to engage in gunfire with officers, who had no choice but to return fire in self-defense.

The officers’ quick decision to fire their weapons struck Wilson-Bogar, and he was subsequently transported to a hospital for medical treatment. According to the Muskogee Police Department, Wilson-Bogar is currently in stable condition, and law enforcement agencies are continuing to investigate the details surrounding his involvement in these violent incidents.

The Fatal Shooting of Rolando Donta McConnell

As the investigation into Wilson-Bogar’s activities deepens, law enforcement agencies have confirmed that the suspect was also responsible for the shooting death of 32-year-old Rolando Donta McConnell, who was killed near North 24th Street West and Topeka Avenue in Muskogee. This incident, which occurred prior to the Oktaha shooting, had already drawn the attention of local authorities due to its violent nature. Investigators believe that McConnell’s death was not an isolated event but part of a string of violent incidents allegedly linked to Wilson-Bogar.

The authorities’ probe into McConnell’s death has added another layer of complexity to the ongoing investigation into Wilson-Bogar’s criminal history. As they piece together the events leading up to the Oktaha shooting and the high-speed pursuit, officials are looking into whether Wilson-Bogar’s actions were premeditated or fueled by other unknown factors.

The Officers Involved in the Shooting

The two officers involved in the shooting of Aaron Wilson-Bogar during the high-speed chase have been identified as Sergeant Bryan Wilkins and Officer Darien Allen of the Muskogee Police Department. Both officers were placed on administrative leave, which is standard procedure in cases involving officer-involved shootings. The Muskogee Police Department confirmed that the officers’ actions are currently under review as part of an ongoing investigation.

Sergeant Wilkins and Officer Allen’s roles in the shooting have drawn scrutiny from both local residents and broader law enforcement communities. It is customary for the OSBI to conduct an independent investigation into all officer-involved shootings in Oklahoma, ensuring that the use of force was justified and in line with department protocols.

As of now, both officers are on paid administrative leave, and no further statements have been made by the Muskogee Police Department regarding their involvement in the shooting. Investigators are carefully examining the circumstances that led to the officers’ decision to return fire at Wilson-Bogar.

The Ongoing Investigation and Community Reactions

The investigation into the Oktaha shooting and Wilson-Bogar’s previous criminal activities is ongoing, and officials are urging the public to provide any information that may assist in piecing together the full scope of the events. Local law enforcement agencies, including the Muskogee County Sheriff’s Office and the OSBI, are working in close collaboration with federal authorities to ensure a thorough and comprehensive investigation.

In Oktaha and surrounding Muskogee County, the community is grappling with the aftermath of this horrific shooting. Residents and local officials are expressing concern over the growing number of violent incidents in the area, and there are calls for heightened security measures to prevent similar events in the future. The victimization of Maxwell and Clay, as well as the violent pursuit of Wilson-Bogar, has caused many to question the broader safety of their communities.

Despite the tragic circumstances, there has been a remarkable show of solidarity from community members who have rallied behind the victims’ families, offering their support and condolences. A GoFundMe page has been established for Maxwell’s family, while Clay’s condition remains closely monitored, with local organizers holding prayer vigils for her recovery.

The Future of Law Enforcement Policies and Practices

The recent spate of violent events linked to Aaron Wilson-Bogar has raised significant questions about law enforcement practices, particularly in the area of high-speed chases and the use of force during arrests. Local leaders have called for a review of police policies regarding the pursuit of suspects involved in violent crimes and the protocols surrounding officer-involved shootings.

While high-speed chases are an essential tool for apprehending dangerous criminals, they carry inherent risks to the safety of officers, suspects, and innocent bystanders. This incident has highlighted the complex balance that law enforcement must strike between ensuring public safety and taking swift action against violent criminals.

Furthermore, the question of mental health and how it intersects with criminal behavior is expected to feature prominently in future discussions regarding the case. Wilson-Bogar’s past violent incidents raise concerns about the role that mental health might have played in his actions, leading many to advocate for a more proactive approach to identifying and addressing mental health issues in law enforcement contexts.

The Role of Local Government and Legal Proceedings

The local government, led by Muskogee County officials, has expressed its commitment to conducting a fair and thorough investigation into the circumstances surrounding the Oktaha shooting, the officer-involved shooting, and Wilson-Bogar’s broader criminal history. District Attorney Dianne McClendon has already indicated that her office will play an active role in reviewing the evidence and determining whether any criminal charges will be filed against Wilson-Bogar or any officers involved in the incidents.

As Wilson-Bogar’s case moves through the judicial system, his legal team will likely challenge the use of deadly force during his apprehension, while the prosecution will present evidence of his violent actions. The outcome of the case will have far-reaching implications for law enforcement practices, particularly regarding the use of force and how such incidents are handled by both officers and the communities they serve.

Final Thoughts

As the investigation continues, the Muskogee community remains shaken by the tragic events that unfolded in Oktaha and Muskogee County. The victims, Amie Maxwell and Kimberly Clay, and the tragic death of Rolando Donta McConnell, have left an indelible mark on the community. While the suspect, Aaron Wilson-Bogar, remains in custody, questions surrounding his motivations, mental health, and the chain of events leading to the Oktaha shooting continue to dominate conversations both locally and nationally.

In the coming weeks and months, the focus will shift to uncovering the full truth behind these tragic events, as law enforcement works tirelessly to piece together the details of Wilson-Bogar’s violent path.